2023 Survey on Overseas Hallyu Status
A Deep Dive Into Hallyu in Italy
The 2000s saw the Hallyu phenomenon take off, which has changed Italians' opinions of Korea. Italy's
97.7% awareness of Korea is an indicator of this change in perception. Italians have one of the highest
levels of cultural pride in Europe. Italy is a country with strong "cultural conservatism" and therefore
does not accept change easily. An in-depth analysis of the 2023 Overseas Hallyu Survey published by the
Korean Foundation for International Cultural Exchange, however, shows some positive outlook for the
future of the Hallyu in Italy. Even though Italy is one of the bottom five countries in terms of the
consumption of Korean cultural content, ranking 22nd out of 26 countries in the Korean Cultural Content
Brand Power Index, more than 80% of the Italian respondents stated that their interest in Korean
cultural content has either increased or remained the same from a year ago. Italy's interest in Korean
cultural content is expected to remain at the current level or grow slightly a year from now.
Furthermore, the 2022 Annual Hallyu Issue conveyed a strong message that Korean culture in Italy
has
moved past the perception of being not very noticeable and is influential to some extent. This is an
encouraging sign for Korean cultural content in Italy and may serve as an opportunity to overcome some
doubts about Hallyu in Italy.
Hyo-shin Kim
Professor at the
Department of Korean Language and Literature,
Daegu Catholic University
This article is an in-depth analysis of the Hallyu in Italy based on the statistical results of the
“2023 Overseas Hallyu Survey” (March 2023) report published by the Korean Foundation for International
Cultural Exchange (KOFICE). The full report can be found on the website of the Korean Foundation for
International Cultural Exchange
www.kofice.or.kr.
1. Introduction
What does Korea look like in Italy? And what does Italy look like in Korea? The answer to both questions
is that each country may not be very noticeable to each other but at the same time, each cannot be
disregarded. While Italy in Korea does not have the image of a superpower like the United States,
Germany, the United Kingdom, or France, its presence cannot be ignored across many parts of culture and
industry. The same goes for Korea in Italy. Among countries in the East, Korea's influence in Italy is
not as strong as China's or Japan's, and it is not deeply rooted among young Italians to prefer Korean
studies to Chinese or Japanese studies. It is worth noting, however, that Sony from Japan was at the
center of Italian electronics stores just 20 to 30 years ago, and now Samsung and LG from Korea have
taken over where Sony used to be. You may even say "Today, there is no single home or office in Italy
that does not have something made in Korea!" Recently in Italy, taekwondo gyms as well as Korean
restaurants have opened here and there (Kim, 2018).
It is quite common for Italians in their 10s and 20s to learn Korean, know about Korea, and enjoy Korean
culture through K-pop. K-pop is something more than just a singing and dancing fad. Although the Korean
Cultural Content Brand Power Index in Italy stands at 52.3, which ranks 22nd out of 26 countries,
Korea's presence in Italy cannot be ignored. In this regard, this report examines the findings of the
Italian Hallyu surveys and outlines the impact of Korean culture in Italy as well as the Hallyu's
prospects for the future.
2. Korean Culture in Italy Viewed from the Annual Hallyu Issue
It was stated in 2018 that Korean culture was "not very noticeable" in Italy. But in just a few years,
Korean culture in Italy has moved past the perception of being "not very noticeable" and is now
influential to some extent, as seen in the 2022 Annual Hallyu Issue. All of Us Are Dead, a
Netflix
Korean drama featuring zombies, took global No. 1 on Netflix in Italy (Feb 2022), Remarriage &
Desires,
another Netflix Korean drama, became the 7th most popular Netflix TV show in Italy (July 2022), and
Secretly Sweetly, a Korean web drama, won the Best Original Idea Award in the Vertical Video
category at
the Digital Media Fest in Rome (Dec 2022). Snowdrop, a drama made by JTBC, was broadcast
exclusively on
Disney Plus in Italy in March 2022, and Bread Barbershop, a Korean animation, signed a license
agreement
with Mondo TV in Italy (May 2022). A BTS concert was streamed live at the Space Cinema in Florence
(March 12, 2022), demonstrating that Korean culture in Italy is no longer "not very noticeable" but now
"noticeable".
In terms of movies, Poet's Room, a virtual reality film about independence activist and poet Yun
Dong-ju, was officially invited to the Venice Immersive section of the 79th Venice International Film
Festival (July 2022), and the Korean film Broker was released in Italy (September 2022).
Regarding
publications, author Lee Soo-ji's picture book Summer is Coming won the Bologna Ragazzi Award
(February
2022), and the Korean webtoon Hell was published in Italy (May 2022). Furthermore, in October
2022, Lee
Seung-hyu (1224–1300), a scholar and writer during the Goryeo Dynasty, published Jewang Ungi, an
Italian
translation of his history book. In the book, Lee described the historical events of Korea and China in
seven-letter poems. As part of an overseas exhibition for images printed in prints, the Italy Art
Festival 2022 (February 2022) was successfully hosted at Galleria Antonio Battaglia in Milan by the
Korea Arts Promotion Agency and the Foreign Exchange Artists Association. Moreover, the regular
collaborative exhibition Drops in the Ocean was hosted (April 2022) by the Korean Cultural Center
in
Italy and the Korean Artists Association in Italy
In addition, during Milan Design Week, the world's largest fashion week, the 2022 Korean Craft
Exhibition Again, From the Earth's Foundation was held at the headquarters of the Feltrinelli
Foundation
in Milan for 6 days from June 7 to 12, 2022, in collaboration with the Ministry of Culture, Sports, and
Tourism and the Korea Craft & Design Foundation. The exhibition was held for the 60th anniversary of
Milan Design Week and the 10th anniversary of the Korean Craft Exhibition in Milan. Again, From the
Earth's Foundation sheds light on the value of crafts made with materials from the earth and the
aesthetics of respect for nature amidst the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and climate change. A total of 22
Korean and Italian designers and craft artists presented more than 100 works in metal, fiber, wood,
glass, and Korean paper (Choi, June 14, 2022)
Images of the Again, From the Earth's Foundation exhibition venue (*source: Korea Craft &
Design Foundation)
3. Perception about Korea in Italy
Although Korean culture may not be the most prevalent in Italy, Italian awareness of Korea is high at
97.7%. Although only 12.8% of the respondents had the correct awareness about Korea (i.e., they know
exactly about Korea), 48.4% roughly knew about Korea, and 36.5% heard of Korea just by name. While
awareness about Korea was fairly common, overall, there was a large proportion of a middle or low level
of awareness. Regarding the respondents demographics, while the percentage of the correct awareness was
generally similar by gender, men (13.3%) were 1% higher than women (12.3%). By age, the highest
percentage of the correct awareness was observed in those in their 20s (16.9%), followed by those in
their 40s (15.5%), 30s (13.5%), and 10s (10.8%). Meanwhile, the lowest percentage of the correct
awareness was observed in those in their 50s (6.2%). The highest percentage of correct awareness about
Korea is observed among those in their 20s who were teenagers in the 2010s when the popularity of the
Hallyu grew exponentially. This coincides with the fact that those who were in their 20s in the early
2000s when the Hallyu became popular are now in their 40s.
A survey on the perceptions about Korea shows that 56.6% of the respondents have positive perceptions
about Korea. In particular, many had positive opinions (4+5) about Korea as an economically advanced
country (54%) and a likable country (52.4%). By contrast, the percentage of positive perceptions about
Korea as a cultural powerhouse (37%) was somewhat lower. Regarding the image of Korea as a cultural
powerhouse, 39.0% of the respondents had a neutral opinion, and 24% had a negative opinion (1+2). These
results may reflect Korean culture as being "not very noticeable". Regarding gender, men (60%) showed a
higher percentage of positive perceptions about Korea than women (53.1%). These results regarding the
perceptions about Korea seem to be related to the fact that there are four questions regarding political
and economic perception out of the six questions, including “Korea as an economically advanced country,”
“Korea as a likable country,” “Korea as an international aid contributor,” and "Korea as a collaborator
rather than a competitor.” By age, those in their 30s (60.4%) had a higher percentage of positive
perception about Korea than other age groups, followed by those in their 40s (60%), 50s (57.5%), 10s
(56%), and 20s (50.7%). The overall positive perception also seems to be somewhat related to the
characteristics of the four questions above. It also has to do with the fact that people in their 10s
and 20s, who are more emotionally invested in Korean culture, have a lower percentage of positive
perceptions.
Similar to other countries, the survey showed the first association with Korea in Italy was K-pop
(17.2%). It was followed by dramas (15.4%) and North Korean nuclear threat, risk of war, and North Korea
(15.0%). The fact that K-pop and dramas ranked 1st and 2nd in the association with Korea suggests that
while Korean culture is "not very noticeable," Italians are exposed to a lot of Korean songs and dramas
without realizing it. Italian men were more likely than Italian women to associate Korea with images,
such as the North Korean nuclear threat, risk of war, and North Korea (17.6%) and tech products and
brands (16.2%), while the women were more likely than the men to associate Korea with Hallyu-related
images, such as K-pop (20.0%) and dramas (18.0%). By age, those in their 20s were more likely to
associate Korea with K-pop (23.6%), dramas (20.0%), and Hallyu celebrities (13.8%) than other age
groups. Those in their 50s were more likely to associate Korea with tech products and brands (18.8%) and
those in their 40s with the Olympics and World Cup (17.2%) than other age groups.
Men (14.4%) were more interested in taekwondo than women (9.8%). By age, the percentage of those
interested in taekwondo was in the order of those in their 40s (17.9%), 50s (15%), 10s (12%), 20s
(10.2%), and 30s (9.3%). After its successful debut as a demonstration sport at the 1988 Seoul Olympics
and the 1992 Barcelona Olympics, taekwondo was selected as an official sport at the 2000 Sydney
Olympics, solidifying its place as a global sport. The fact that taekwondo was included as an official
sport in the Sydney Olympics may be related to a lot of interest in taekwondo among those in their 40s
today, who enjoyed watching it in their 20s.
In December 2000, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) approved taekwondo as an official sport for
the 2004 Olympic Games in Athens. Also, the Italian Taekwondo Federation was recognized as the official
national sports federation in 2001. The Third World Taekwondo Grand Prix was held in Rome, Italy from
June 3 to 5, 2022. It was held in Foro Italico, which has hosted some of Italy's biggest sports events
since it opened in 1932, and the world's top 32 taekwondo athletes competed to earn a critical score to
qualify for the 2024 Paris Olympics. Alongside the Grand Prix in Rome, over 2,000 young athletes from
all over Europe competed in Kim & Liù, the biggest taekwondo competition in the world for athletes aged
6 to 11. Furthermore, a Taekwondo demonstration team from Korea made a tour across cities in Italy to
celebrate and promote the World Taekwondo Grand Prix. A performance by the World Taekwondo Demonstration
Team hosted by the Consulate General of Korea in Milan in collaboration with the Italian Taekwondo
Federation was successfully presented to Italian people at Piazza del Duomo in Milan on May 21, 2022,
prior to the Grand Prix. The taekwondo demonstration not only showcased the powerful and disciplined
essence of taekwondo in front of tens of thousands of Italians and tourists from all around the world,
who gathered in Piazza del Duomo to watch Radio Italia Live, Italy's largest outdoor music concert, but
also captivated the audience with eye-catching elements to enjoy, including five-color cloth and flower
petals (Baek, June 14, 2022).
Poster for the Third World Taekwondo Grand Prix in Rome (*source: Korea Craft & Design
Foundation)
4. Italy and the Competitiveness of the Hallyu
A higher brand power index was typically seen in the genre of content with a higher experience
percentage. When the content was divided into genres based on experience percentage and brand power
index, dramas, food, movies, games, animation, and music had experience percentages and brand power
indices that were either similar to or higher than the average. Webtoons, publications, and variety
shows were the content genres with lower experience percentages and brand power indices than the
average.
Women in their 10s, 20s, 30s, and 40s and men in their 20s, 30s, and 40s, respectively, demonstrated a greater percentage of experience and a higher brand power index compared to the average.
The percentage of experiencing Korean cultural content in Italy ranged from 20.6 to 60.4%. The most
experienced content included dramas (60.4%), food (57.0%), and movies (55.6%), while the least
experienced content included webtoons (20.6%), publications (25.6%), and variety shows (25.8%). There
were also some differences in gender, with men more likely to experience games (60.9%) and animation
(48.8%) than women. Meanwhile, women were more likely to experience fashion (44.4%) and beauty (53.1%)
content than men. By age, those in their 20s (66.2%) were the most likely to experience dramas, followed
by those in their 20s (62.7%) for food, those in their 40s (62.1%) for movies, and 55.1% in those in
their 10s and 20s for games. Animation was likely experienced among those in their 20s (52%), music
among those in their 20s (60%), and fashion among those in their 40s (44.1%). Beauty showed the highest
percentage among those in their 20s (43.1%), followed by variety shows among those in their 20s (33.8%),
publications among those in their 20s (31.1%), and webtoons among those in their 20s (27.1%). Among 11
genres of Korean cultural content in Italy, 9 genres were most experienced among those in their 20s,
which demonstrates that those in their 20s had a much higher experience percentage than other age
groups.
Across all 11 categories of Korean cultural content, "not interested in Korean content" was the most
frequently cited explanation for Italians' lack of experience to Korean cultural content. 63.6% of the
respondents said they had no plans to use any Korean cultural content, however if they do, food (19.5%)
and dramas (10.9%) were the content they were most likely to use in the future. Music (70.5%), beauty
(62.9%), food (52.7%), and webtoons (52.0%) were the most user-friendly categories of Korean cultural
content. Notably, women (74.9%) found it easier to use music than men (66.3%), with people in their 50s
showed the highest level (77.8%).
Regarding access paths for Korean cultural content, the main access path for Korean dramas, variety
shows, movies, music, and animation was online and mobile. The percentage of online and mobile access
was very high across 11 cultural content genres, ranging from 82.8 to 92%. Publications had the highest
percentage of access through global sites and apps (43.5%), webtoons had the highest percentage of
access through Naver Webtoons (38.3%), and games had the highest percentage in online direct play
(56.5%). For content related to food, beauty, and fashion, the most popular access paths were social
media videos and photos (57.5%, 64.7%, and 50.6%, respectively). Fashion and beauty also showed
relatively high percentages of access through Korean video content, while food had a high percentage of
access through YouTube videos (42.8%). The most used online and mobile platforms for dramas, variety
shows, movies, music, and animation were Netflix and Amazon Prime, and the top platform for the overall
percentage of content access was Netflix, with 82.4%, especially for dramas. It was followed by Amazon
Prime and YouTube. YouTube (75.9%) was the most used platform for music
In terms of the purchase paths of Korean cultural content, global sites, and apps were the most popular
purchase paths for fashion, beauty, and food consumers. Korean websites and apps ranked 3rd for fashion
and beauty, following local websites and apps, indicating a higher response rate than local offline
stores. For food, local offline stores ranked 2nd with 39.9%, followed by local sites and apps with
26.4%. Meanwhile, Korean offline stores ranked lower across fashion, beauty, and food.
The likeability of Korean cultural content among the Italian respondents was generally high.
Specifically, the top three popular categories were above 64.0%, including movies (69.5%), beauty
(69.3%), and variety shows (64.6%). On the other hand, the three least favored genres included fashion,
animation, and music.
Squid Game, a Netflix Korean series, was the most preferred Korean drama with 46.1%.
Parasite (16.8%)
ranked 1st in movies, Pucca (24.3%) ranked 1st in animation, and Marvel Future Revolution
(20.1%) ranked 1st in games, followed by Ragnarok (14.7%).
In terms of overall cultural content, the United States ranked first, but Japan ranked first in terms of
animation and webtoons. In dramas, variety shows, movies, and music, the United States gathered a
response rate of more than 50%, which was quite higher than the 2nd place. Korea ranked 2nd or 3rd in
webtoons (18.3%), dramas (14.4%), variety shows (13.1%), beauty (11%), games (9.7%), music (8.4%), and
movies (7.5%). For publications, the response rate for Korea was 8.4%, ranking the 5th, while Korea was
outside the top five in fashion and food categories.
5. Conclusions
By examining the survey outcomes of the top countries by cultural content, we were able to grasp the
competitiveness of the Korean Wave in Italy. We also discovered why Italy ranks 22nd out of 26 countries
in the Korean Cultural Content Brand Power Index. Korea is regarded as a nation whose cultural presence
is not particularly obvious but cannot be disregarded. Moreover, the most common response from Italians
when asked why they hadn't experienced Korean cultural content in Italy was "not interested in Korean
content," which is a harsh reality Hallyu must face to increase its competitiveness. On the other hand,
it is somewhat reassuring that 43.2% of the participants reported that exposure to Korean cultural
content improved their overall opinion of Korea.
The 2000s saw the Hallyu phenomenon take off, which has changed Italians' opinions of Korea.
Italy's 97.7% awareness of Korea is an indicator of this change in perception. Italians have one of the
highest levels of cultural pride in Europe. Italy is a country with strong "cultural conservatism" and
therefore does not accept change easily.
The aforementioned survey outcomes, however, show some positive outlook for the future of the Hallyu in
Italy. More than 80% of the respondents said that interest in Korean cultural content in Italy was
similar or increased compared to a year ago. It is expected to increase slightly a year from now. Most
significantly, over 25% of respondents said they would be willing to pay for Korean cultural content in
the categories of food (35.1%), drama (27.3%), games (27.1%), and movies (25.3%). Dramas showed the
highest net recommendation index of 21.1%, with 26.7% of the users actively recommending the dramas and
5.6% of the users not recommending them, suggesting that dramas are the only type of content that draws
in more new users than other genres.
The
2022 Annual Hallyu Issue conveyed a strong message that Korean culture in Italy has moved
past the
perception of being not very noticeable and is influential to some extent. This is an encouraging sign
for Korean cultural content in Italy and may serve as an opportunity to overcome some doubts about the
Hallyu in Italy.